Showing posts with label judgment. Show all posts
Showing posts with label judgment. Show all posts

Wednesday, April 20, 2011

What is a "Dirty" Hit These Days?

"What's the Buzz All About?"




Head contact...

Concussions...

Targeting the head...

Hitting from Behind...

Charging?....

All buzz words these days in hockey circles. I can't turn on Versus, the VS "Overtime" Show, NHL "On the Fly", nor NHL Radio on XM/Sirius without hearing them talk on and on and on about the aforementioned buzz words.

Before we even get on and on and on about the buzz, I have a video and a link for you and a recent NHL playoff article for you:


Zebra TV - Episode 3 from J.B. Olson on Vimeo.
Link referenced in the above video: http://youtu.be/m55RtBUyKcA



RECENT BOURNE ARTICLE LINK: http://www.hockeyprimetime.com/news/columns/when-clean-hits-look-dirty
(psst...I love the writing of Justin Bourne, former NCAA - Alaska-Anchorage - and Minor Pro Player)

RECENT NHL PLAYOFF STUFF:






*******************
A few things I would like to say, as an ex-player first, and then, as a hockey referee second:

1. I played to hurt guys. Not injure them, but hurt them. What's the difference? The difference is (a) making a guy think twice about tangling in the corner with me again, and (b) I want that guy to feel the "sting" NOT (I repeat *NOT*) to put him in the hospital.

Hockey is a great sport because it can be beautiful, artistic, and at the same time BARBARIC. Me...I liked the BARBARIC side of the sport as much as any.

2. I think a lot of the increase in injuries is because we don't call CHARGING enough.

There are a number of reasons we don't call charging enough...like, does the guy go 100 mph and then set his feet prior to the hit, thus, negating the "taking two or more strides thing?

How about the fact that most times a ref calls charging everybody in the building screams "INJUSTICE!"?(well...half of the people involved).

How about the fact that players are stronger, bigger, and a whole lot faster than before, and no one seems to like the notion of cutting down on speed? Let's face it, there are some big dudes out there moving full tilt.

How about the fact that some of these things happen because everyone is moving full tilt and it is really hard to make an adjustment when we are taking "miliseconds". All guys have on their mind is "finish the hit". All guys are coached to do is to "finish the hit". When you have that demand running through your brain, and the guy you are checking suddenly turns or ducks...well...it's damn hard to stop your momentum.

*********************
What's the answer? I don't have one. I just know that some of the things I have mentioned here are facts that are tough to disprove. Real tough.


(note: hitting from behind is not tough...it is gutless, but look at the Johan Franzen video in the "Bourne Article" and tell me whether Shane Doan was being gutless or not. I say "not" because...well...he was moving FAST!)

Thursday, November 26, 2009

It Takes a Stiff Back Bone

Alex Ovechkin gets booted at home.  Does that take a stiff back bone, or not??:










When I go back through my memory banks of my mind, I try to think about memorable times that I had some lopsided marbles when it comes to penalty calls.  Believe me, there have been numerous times when one team deserves more penalties than the other team.  And I would say that is true with the new standard of play now more than it used to be.


Back to racking my mind, going through my mental database of lopsided penalty calls.  Guess what?  90% of them happened against the visiting team OR at some "neutral site" or event, like a National Championship or All-Star Festival, where there is no home crowd per se.


I can think of five times, three of which involved a WCHA game:


  • The time the Gophers took just a boat load of penalties against Mankato, and Chris Harrington took a 10 minute Misconduct for shattering his stick over the cross bar, in protest of a power play 5 on 3 goal.  This all happened in the 2nd period, and when we left the ice at the conclusion of that period, I can't remember any other time where the building actually SHOOK from the thunderous "boo's" that showered down upon us.
  • The time UMD was playing UND in Duluth, and a number of calls went against the home team, the last of which was a called off goal at the 3rd period buzzer, which would have tied the game and sent it into OT (this was wayyyyy before replay).  That was the one time I had never before seen so much garbage rain down on the ice.  There was a fan that tried to attack the referee, and this guy got whooped up on by the cops.  We were escorted out the building.
  • Once at UMD for a holiday tournament, UMD was playing Boston University.  There were numerous calls that went against BU, all deserved, and at the end of the game, I saw a coach against ref tirade that was something like this [see video].
  • I seriously felt like the locals were coming after me with tars, and feathers, lighted torches, and pitch forks once in Green Bay...I was reffing Green Bay against Waterloo in the old Brown County Coliseum (what a dump), and the home team took the majority of the penalties.  At about the 10:00 mark of the 3rd period, Waterloo called a time out, and the PA blasted "Three Blind Mice" and put my name up on the scoreboard message board.  My name was called out for the rest of the game, and at the conclusion of the game, the home team's coach told me what he really felt about my performance that night.  I was also escorted out of the building by Brown County's finest that night.
  • In Proctor, MN, at a Pee Wee A tournament,  my partner and I rang Proctor up for a bunch of penalties in the championship game of their Invitational Tourney.  That was my first introduction to really being verbally accosted by a mob, because you had to walk through the lobby to get to the refs room (which, I kid you not, was a broom closet!).  We got verbally abused again when leaving the building, and I was told to "Never Come Back!"  Well...that was about 1993, and I haven't been back since.
What's my point here?  I will just say something like this -- whenever the home team gets swept in a WCHA series, everyone is grumpy, angry, downright hostile.  I can go through my mind and think of many other instances where I had lopsided penalties, but they typically all involve the visiting team.  


I am just saying it is human nature, and if you try to combat this by being a 100% "Book" Referee, you will not go very far.  "Book" referees are the strict disciplinarians who call everything right by the book. Theses guys are told they have "no feel" for the game.  I agree.  A "Book" Referee can be good...but...he will never be great.


You want more insight on this?  Join our [Ultimate Officials Ref Camp].  Or [email me for more info].



Tuesday, November 10, 2009

Head Shots?

What in the Wide World of Sports is going on here...Petr Sykora out for the MN Wild out...the NHL GM's are looking into it...the worlds' goofiest helmet look...here's what Boston GM says:

"I don't like the fact that there are these violent hits to the head. But also, there's a balance that you have to have," Chiarelli said as the Bruins practiced at Ristuccia Arena in preparation for Tuesday night's game against the Pittsburgh Penguins at TD Garden. "If you start legislating contact out of the game, it's not going to be a very entertaining game. So I guess I feel strongly about continuing to discuss it and try to find solutions. But you have to be very careful.........."There's nothing magical," he said. "You have to instruct the referees properly. There's a threshold, there's an element of intent."

OK, so what's the proper way?  Only thing I can think about is late, avoidable hits, and all coaches seem to hate that penalty (unless it's called against the other team).  Why?  They want guys to finish their check to send a message.  Well...I am all of 'getting after it during play' and letting them 'battle', but late hits?...come on.  I don't see the need.

PLUS...I want you to explain to me the difference between this hit:

No penalty, no suspension:


And this hit: No penalty, one game suspension:


Can someone please help?

Well...I prefer a different kind of shot to a head shot (I know, I've done this before...too funny):
You Call That a Shot?

Friday, November 6, 2009

Do We Have a Problem Here...


Whenever I talk to people who know absolutely nothing about hockey, they usually ask, "Why is there fighting allowed in hockey?"  Well, I have to tell them that it is only allowed in "fighting" leagues, like the pros, minors, and juniors.  Then I get asked, "Why do they allow it, when the Olympics don't?"  Then I have to say something about 'tradition, getting aggression out vs. high sticking, or some other company line.' 

I had such a guy ask me, "What exactly is charging?"  I told it is taking three or more stides to check someone.  He asked me, realy serious like/kind of dumbfounded..."Why isn't it called?"  I looked at him.  Blankly.  Told some b.s. about tradition, aggression, and some company line.

What's the big talk so far?

How about this: A definite run

Nick Leddy breaks his jaw: Teach = How? Who? (good luck)

TSN weighs in on the issue: article here

Mike Richards hit: NHL says 'no suspension' but WCHA says penalty (see Leddy)?

Here's all that I know:

  • hockey is fast right now, and getting faster
  • when the NHL "openend up the ice" the running-type hits increased
  • a lot of hockey people want this to be a part of the game
  • charging only seems to be called if someone gets hurt
So, I got no answers.  If I were to take a stand, I would say that charging should be enforced.  I also know deep down inside that you are going to have a lot of pissed off coaches when penalties are called on hits like the one on Nick Leddy (especially when a broken jaw is a one in one hundred thing - hope you saw it...I can't find a picture or video on it anywhere...it was very, very similar to the Mike Richards hit).

(Ultimate Officials Ref Camp Members will get my 'real' thoughts on this, plus inside info - contact me to join the camp and get my inside scoop).

Thursday, September 24, 2009

Predicting the Future - Ref style

I went to a Jr. A Tier III game last night.  I was there to collect data on the game, like what the referee was doing, work/rest ratios, stoppages, and so on.  My reason for doing all the "geeked-up" type stuff is that I want to break the game down into its most basic elements to better instruct hockey referees.  This is key to really giving a guy an edge where he may need one.  Either physically (for example, do you know how many times a ref in the 1-2 system will sprint the ENTIRE length of the ice -- all 200 feet -- in any given game?  I do.), or mentally (do you know how many times a linesman will have to be aware of icings/offsides in any given game?  I do.).

What does this and a hill of beans mean to you?



It means you can predict the future.



Before you go on further, I want you to read this [link] (please be sure to come back :)

Did you know that Gretzky stepped down as the coach of the Coyotes today?

(hint/hint: He was really, really good at being one step ahead of the competition)

Gretzky's Last Game as a Player (and other stuff):


Q: What does all of this have to do with each other???


A: Being one step ahead of the play (or...predicting the future).

The best refs are the one's who are one step ahead of the play.  They anticipate actions, retaliations, sometimes really bad shtuff, and even what type of game you are going to have.  Now, I am not quite as good as Carnac (that Johnny Carson picture up there, for all you young punks, he was on the Tonight Show before Jay Leno -- hehehe), but with my arsenal of data, I did correctly predict the 3rd period of last night's game.  Pure luck?  Nope.  You would be AMAZED how uncanny it is that hockey games move in predictable patterns.  Game in, game out, season in, season out, they move in very predictable patterns.  There happened to be a supervisor at that game last night, and I told him exactly what was going to happen in the 3rd period.  I was right.  No luck involved.  Just a bunch of yellow legal pads full of notes, stats, skating diagrams, and situations. 

Wanna have that edge?  Wanna predict the future of your games, be one step ahead like Gretzky and Nate Lawson?  Come hang out with [me].

Or just watch old Tonight Show reruns.

Tuesday, June 2, 2009

How Come Nobody Asks me About this Rule??

Is is All About the etcetra??? No one, and I repeat, no one asked me about this rule. No one mentioned it...(when I saw that fight happen I thought, "It's in the last five minutes! They're done the next game!"

On the flip side, EVERYONE and their dog asked me about the play where Zetterberg put his hand on the puck on Osgood's back, all while in the crease (see second clip - you'll have to fast forward to the 6:00 mark of the video). They all wanted to know, "is that a penalty shot?" My answer is in my Game 1 Live Blog notes...


For some reason ESPN got rid of that video...here's a funny/tragic one instead:


Game 1